Monday, November 16, 2026

Annotated Bibliography: Social media, memes, and math belonging


Barba, K. (2020). The mathematical mindsets and mathematical identities revealed in social media discourse. Journal of Mathematics Education at Teachers College, 11(2), 23–34. https://doi.org/10.7916/jmetc.v11i2.7833     This paper looks at YouTube comments on a viral math problem to see what people's online reactions reveal about their attitudes and identities around math. It points out common clichés like the “White male math myth” and the “lone genius” trope in these comments and shows that people with a fixed mindset (believing that math ability is innate) tend to create pecking orders and put others down. Commenters often saw such viral problems as tricky, deceptive puzzles designed to incite controversy, and the author argues these problems test speed over deep conceptual understanding. Ultimately, fixed-mindset comments left other commenters feeling alienated, anxious, and "dumb," whereas commenters with a growth mindset (opposite to a fixed mindset) built one another up and handled mistakes with resilience.


The viral math problem discussed in the paper

Benoit, G., & Salopek, G. (2023). What do you meme? An investigation of social media and mathematics identity. Journal of Urban Mathematics Education, 16(1), 40–71.     This paper explores how social media and internet memes shape the way high school students see themselves as math learners. It highlights how demographic trends, White male-dominated meme tropes, and strict gender stereotypes send messages about who is supposed to be good at math. Through complex calculus jokes and memes about failing, math is mostly shown as confusing, nightmarish, out of reach, and deeply frustrating. The authors show that (for 31 high school students from New York City across various demographics) seeing so much negativity online made students feel alienated and publicly shamed, which hurt their confidence and made them want to disengage. Bini, G., & Robutti, O. (2020). Is this the real life? Connecting mathematics across cultures. In Proceedings of the CIEAEM 71 conference, Quaderni di Ricerca in Didattica (Mathematics) (Vol. 7, pp. 455–461). G.R.I.M., University of Palermo.     This paper looks at how 10th-grade students connect math with their everyday lives by making their own math memes. Students jump into making these memes to get laughs and approval from peers, blending everyday youth culture with classroom topics. By tying school concepts to familiar humor, math comes across as approachable, creative, and actually relevant to real life. Crossing those boundaries encourages everyone to join in, helping quieter students find their voice and feel like part of the math community, and so the authors argue that memes can be a useful educational tool. Bini, G., Robutti, O., & Bikner-Ahsbahs, A. (2022). Maths in the time of social media: Conceptualizing the internet phenomenon of mathematical memes. International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology, 53(6), 1257–1296. https://doi.org/10.1080/0020739X.2020.1807069     This paper explores the rise of online math memes and how people use them to talk through their math ideas and connect with one another. In the online meme groups they studied, fitting in was all about cleverness and helping each other out, rather than relying on traditional classroom hierarchies. Blending visuals and text, these memes made math feel surprising, funny, understandable, and genuinely interesting instead of dry or rigid. Open discussions and figuring out jokes together fostered engagement, peer support, and a sense of shared connection. Hammonds, K. E., & Martin, W. G. (2023, June 21). Include mathematical memes into your routine! Association of Mathematics Teacher Educators. https://amte.net/tech-talk/2023/06/include-mathematical-memes-your-routine     This article looks at how teachers can bring math memes into their regular classroom routines to spark conversations about math beliefs and student identity. It emphasizes valuing the different ways students contribute as well as pushing back against harmful math stereotypes so every learner feels capable of doing math. Instead of hiding the struggle, these memes blend common frustrations with humor, transforming learning math into something more approachable and shared. The authors argue that memes give students a low-pressure way to participate, reducing boredom, building ownership over their learning, and encouraging confidence and perseverance. Hidayatullah, A. R., & Suprapti, E. (2020). The affect [sic] of the internet and social media: Mathematics learning environment context. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 469(1), Article 012080. https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/469/1/012080     This paper looks at how the internet and social media are changing the way students learn math. It focuses on millennial and Gen Z students using online spaces to help each other learn, rather than having to wait for the next class or rely solely on the teacher as the primary conveyor of information. The authors contrast old labels of math as boring, rigid, and too hard with instant-help tools like Photomath and YouTube tutorials. Using these digital tools helps students move past solo frustration toward online teamwork, making them feel more included and confident. Hu, X., Zuo, H., Lai, C., Zhu, G., Guo, J., & Tan, H. L. (2024). Is social media use for math learning beneficial for ethnic minority students' math identity? A socialization perspective. British Journal of Educational Technology, 55(1), 363–378. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjet.13359     This paper examines how using social media to learn math affects ethnic minority high school students and how they see themselves in the subject. It looks closely at how students balance their cultural backgrounds with school expectations and deal with biased stereotypes about who has a “natural” aptitude for math. Unlike high-pressure traditional classrooms, social media offers a casual, low-risk, and supportive space to explore math. The findings suggest that learning math through social media helps students build a stronger sense of belonging, countering harmful math stereotypes they may encounter. Penland, A. (2021, May 6). Mathematical memes: Fun and insightful. Mathematical Association of America. https://www.mathvalues.org/masterblog/mathematical-memes-fun-and-insightful     This blog post shares how a professor used optional meme assignments in a college calculus class to boost participation and build a better classroom environment. Keeping the meme prompts occasional and voluntary ensured that non-math majors and less tech-savvy students were never left out while still helping shape the class culture. Although common internet memes can often depict math as a source of frustration, students who designed their own memes in the calculus class reframed the subject to something humourous, surprising, and understandable. The author suggests that humour gives students a safe, low-stakes way to open up about struggles, easing math anxiety and building confidence.


Just a couple of math memes




Thursday, October 22, 2026

Bouncing around ideas

I've been circling around a few different topics, changing my mind from day to day. After a clarifying conversation with Hendo I've decided to keep the topic of math in the media. After searching for articles on the topic I may refine the question with time.

Current question: How do media representations of mathematics shape students’ perceptions of who belongs in mathematics, and what are the implications for teaching math?

I may broaden the focus from specifically looking at the sense of belonging and instead ask "what is the influence of media", but I am still undecided on this change as belonging in math is a primary goal of mine as a math teacher. I am sure this will become more refined as I read more about the research and better develop my own understanding.

APPA style reference

Thursday, October 15, 2026

Inquiring about our inquiry projects

Today we chatted with our colleagues about our inquiry topics. Together we made a class poem comprised by the "nutshell" of our inquiry projects. Walking around the room it was fantastic to hear what people are curious about and already start bouncing ideas. It made me quite excited to see how these will all come to be. In that conversation I decided to switch my topic to math representations in the media and how it impacts students.

Rock on Mirror at the Louisiana Museum in Copenhagen

My topic:

How do media representations of mathematics shape students’ perceptions of who belongs in mathematics, and what are the implications for teaching math?

Three categories to analyze:

  1. Who belongs in mathematics? (Gender, race, culture, and socioeconomic background, stereotypes)
  2. What does mathematics look and feel like? (How does media portray math itself: intimidating, boring, inaccessible, interesting, knowable, surprising)
  3. How do representations affect belonging? (Belonging and exclusion, confidence, motivation to participate)

Why it matters to me personally and professionally:

Back when I was an undergraduate student I wondered about who we are told gets to do math, and what the impact of that is on our sense of belonging in the subject. There were many movies about the tortured genius, brilliance, and obsession, typically all featuring the same white male demographic. As time went on representation widened with a recognition of institutional barriers for women and people of colour. Because the internet is a firehose, math representations can be found all over the place, but there are still trends within the multitudes. I am curious about how the varied categories might impact students' experience of math. For example, trends like the "girl math" meme could perpetuate gender stereotypes about who gets to do math. But I am not naively saying all media is negative, there exist many helpful videos that explain mathematical concepts that can get students more interested in math (think Numberphile).

Painting with a wide brush I think it's fair to say that teenagers love phones and media. I think it will be fascinating to see what they might be seeing and consider the impact that has.

Keywords and phrases:

Math in popular media, math stereotypes, positive representations of mathematics, sense of belonging in mathematics, diverse mathematical role models, representation and inclusion in math

What will not be included:

General student achievement, comparisons of teaching methods, or all barriers to equity in math. I want to focus specifically on media representations and their potential influence on students’ confidence and belonging, rather than assuming all representations are harmful.

Other questions and insights:

  • How can media representations either discourage students or inspire them to see themselves as capable mathematicians?
  • What makes a mathematical role model relatable to students?
  • How can teachers use positive representations while critically examining harmful stereotypes?
  • I want to explore how media can be both a barrier to belonging and a potential tool for fostering confidence and inclusion.

Indigenizing the math class: a starting discussion

Today we discussed Indigenizing the math classroom, a topic I would love to see continue in further classes. I appreciated the openness and honesty of all my classmates as we talked through how this might be achieved in an authentic way. I do worry about trying an activity and having it be received as "the tipi is a cone" example of misrepresentation instead of the "star blanket" example which Dr. Ed Doolittle described as genuine. I was getting confused about where to draw the line of what's authentic and what's not. But then I also have his words in my head to not let fear stop you from trying. After the discussion it helped me to zoom out a bit, moving away from specific exercises, and coming back to the First Peoples Principles of Learning. This of course still doesn't give me prescriptive steps on how to Indigenize the math class, but it feels like a good place to start.

For me I think Indigenizing the math class is less about particular activities and more about changing how mathematics is taught. How can students learn from their environment? How can math be more collaborative and community oriented? Again, these are all just starting points and are quite broad topics. I would also want to incorporate Indigenous ways of knowing local to where I am teaching (an idea Kieran mentioned in discussion that I thought was important).

Sunday, October 11, 2026

Inquiry project topic: movement in the math class

Define your question:

How does incorporating movement through kinesthetic learning influence student engagement and mathematical understanding in secondary mathematics classrooms?

Analyze your topic into concepts:

  1. Kinesthetic learning: Research ways by which students can learn mathematical concepts through physical actions, movement, and hands-on experiences (i.e. looking for specific exercises that could be used in a classroom setting)
  2. Student motivation and engagement: Research how incorporating movement may influence students’ interest, willingness to participate, attention, and motivation during math lessons (i.e. what is the impact of such exercises on participation)
  3. Understanding: Do physical activities help students visualize abstract mathematical ideas, recognize patterns, and develop conceptual understanding? (i.e. what is the impact of such exercises on understanding)
Note that concept 1 explains approaches that could be taken in the classroom, and 2 and 3 explore the impact of such approaches.

Motivations:

I am interested in exploring how movement can transform the experience of learning mathematics. Sitting for long periods and being expected to “pay attention” that whole time can be tiring and disengaging. Movement offers an opportunity to make learning more active, embodied, and memorable. It can shift the power dynamic of the classroom, as students and teachers move together (instead of just the teacher standing with students sitting), creating space for vulnerability and shared experience. When recalling a concept, students can draw on their physical experiences as well as their intellectual understanding, which I suspect supports long-term memory and deeper learning. This is something I've wondered about for quite some time as a student myself. Spending time in the orchard garden, particularly the lesson where we traced the sun’s path, inspired me to explore this topic further.

Some cute mushrooms on the North shore

Thursday, October 8, 2026

Lessons from Dr. Ed Doolittle

There were two main pauses that stuck with me from the conversation with Dr. Ed Doolittle. The first was about coming from an authentic place. He gave the example of Indigenous knowledge being misrepresented in the classroom (the tipi being described as a cone), and how we don't just want to force and reduce Indigenous lessons into mathematical categories. Authenticity is not, then, simply about adding Indigenous examples to existing lessons; it requires respect, accuracy, humility, a willingness to learn, and a willingness to recognize our shortcomings. I loved the idea of bringing in elders to teach on topics that resonate with them. Students can learn math related to those topics, but also not just math.

Which brings me to my second pause: that the best math lessons are not just about math. The idea that we can teach math but through the context of a much broader body of knowledge. He discussed how you could bring in an elder to teach a lesson about a canoe paddle. This could involve measurement and geometry while also exploring its history, purpose, craftsmanship, relationship to the land and water, and cultural significance. This is a more holistic approach to learning. This helps students understand not just the math itself but how it fits into a larger understanding of the world.

On a personal note I was delighted that Dr. Ed Doolittle teaches in Regina. I did my undergraduate degree at the University of Regina and have had the pleasure of visiting FNU on campus which is an absolutely beautiful building. Below are some pictures from the FNU website (links included below).


Weaving words

We started our morning making rope from grass and later weaved words, writing poems inspired by the constant 'e'. I had an excellent time with both activities and enjoyed how they informed one another. It was interesting to find hidden or meta meanings in the construction of our poems. We played with the idea of fear and love in our halloween poem, inspired by the double meaning of the word "boo" as both a spooky scare and also an affectionate pet name. The primary focus of our poem was on Halloween, and the hidden message we tried to weave throughout was this theme of love (which we hinted at in the drawings on our paint cards). We also really enjoyed how some of names of the paint cards fit our theme and the words of our poem, another layer that adds to the richness of the text.

I really loved the idea of using digits of an irrational number to create a poem. This provides a constraint that makes everyone feel like a poet--all you have to do is pick a phrase for each number. After class I was thinking about how it would be interesting to assign a music note to each number and hear the song you and your irrational number have created together. Here is one I made in the key of e minor with 10 decimal places of e, 2.7182818284.

  • 1: f#
  • 2: d
  • 4: g maj chord
  • 7: g
  • 8: e minor chord 7
Don't mind my messy scratch sheet music!

Here is a little recording

 
Creating our poem

     
My little grass rope in the garden

Annotated Bibliography: Social media, memes, and math belonging

Barba, K. (2020). The mathematical mindsets and mathematical identities revealed in social media discourse. Journal of Mathematics Education...