On reading Grant and Zeichner's description of the "reflective teacher", it felt remarkably similar to how Skemp described "relational understanding" (for those of us in EDCP 342). Though the former is centered on critically thinking about who we want to be as teachers and the latter is about learning math itself, both emphasize the why behind the how. The way I see it is that by taking the time to examine ones beliefs a priori (especially those we take for granted), we strengthen our intuitions and responses when faced with new scenarios, ensuring that our actions better line up with our values. This could be compared to how when one has a relational understanding of math it becomes easier to transfer knowledge to novel problems, questions, conjectures.
I believe the advice to continue to question and examine our own beliefs as well as the status quo is extremely important as it lays the foundation of our conscious and unconscious actions. For me, almost ironically, this is one belief that will never go stale. This is why the article felt just as relevant today as it would have been in the 80s, and honestly before that too.
By nature teaching is a political career. Who controls information and how it is delivered is political. As the authors say on page 112, "There is no such thing as a neutral educational activity". I am sure we can all think of examples of lessons from our youth that, upon reflecting now, we would have not accepted from our teachers. I grew up in a town where the primary resource was training military personnel and I've now come to see the majority of my history education as government propaganda. As a student I felt there was something off about what we were learning but didn't have the intellectual foundation to push back as I would as an adult. I wonder if the content of our learning would have been different if these teachers were exposed to this article and tried to become reflective teachers themselves? I should hope so.

What an important connection with your own experiences growing up in that place; not everyone sees how political education is (because it’s about enculturating new generations into a culture)!
ReplyDelete