A theme I noticed throughout the paper was just how hard coordinators of campus gardens have to work to convince universities (administrators?) of the benefits of the garden, all while the benefits of the traditional classroom are taken for granted. In general, people are used to being indoors. They've gotten used to the comforts this brings (mostly stable temperature, taditional chair to sit on) while the discomforts are taken for granted or not even noticed (unnatural lighting, uninspiring architecture, and as someone who can't sit still I'll list traditional chairs here too!). When people aren't used to being outside, I think the discomforts can seem glaring (temperature, unexpected noises, wet ground), and it may take awhile for the comforts to be noticed (the birds singing, the sunshine warming your clothes, the smell of soil).
I think people are up for this reframing. After all, we are natural creatures living unnaturally, but teaching in the garden puts us one step closer to our "human nature". Not to mention, the orchard garden provides a particularly significant comfort not often found in a traditional classroom: food. If we're hungry, we can't learn. The garden provides many options to aid hunger and in the moment students can snack if they need (I know I have!).
In coursework as teacher candidates we've learning a lot about the importance of failure in learning. Encouraging effort and strategies rather than "the right answer" so that students will build resilience and confidence. I've always felt that gardening is an exercise in failure. Every year I try new things and some things work, others don't. And each year I adjust based on what I've learned or try something entirely new. It's a slow, iterative, annual learning that means sometimes I get lots of kale and no tomatoes, and other times I'll get one very small proud squash. There is even the added joy of the surprise plants that just pop up in the spring. In class they've told us that we're not just teaching our specialized subject areas, we're teaching how to learn. The way I see it learning in a garden ties you directly to this gardening experience which has so many lessons to share.

Lovely, insightful writing, Tara! I also can’t sit still for very long… I really like your thoughts in comfort and discomfort in both settings. And so cool that you ate (a bite) at the renowned Noma (greenhouse)!!
ReplyDelete